Copyright exceptions - beware the law of unintended consequences

Dear reader

You'll recall that Professor Hargreaves' Review recommended two areas for change - copyright licensing and copyright exceptions. On licensing, there are the proposed schemes for orphan works licensing  and  extended collective licensing (ECL), the framework for which is in the Enterprise & Regulatory Reform Act 2013.  This isn't likely to be before 2014. The Govermnent  has published a FactSheet here.

But the process of overhauling copyright exceptions in the UK's Copyright, Designs & Patents Act, which started with implementation of the EC Copyright Directive of 2000, temporarily gathered - then lost - momentum with the 2006 Gowers Review, re-started with the 2011 Hargreaves Review is now once again on the move. On June 7, the IPO published the first pieces of draft secondary legislation for technical review until July 17 - not long!. They deal with exceptions for private copying, parody, quotation and public administration. The draft legislation can be found here. Draft legislation for  the remaining exceptions will follow shortly.

In 'Modernising Copyright', its response to the Hargreaves Review, the Government accepted Hargreaves' proposals to update copyright exceptions in nine areas - private copying, education, quotation, text and data mining, parody, research and private study, disabilities, preservation and public administration and reporting.

Whilst updating certain copyright exceptions may make sense, the devil is in the detail. What makes the stakes so high is that the 'digital shift' means a move from the sale of physical product, including creative content on fixed digital media like DVSs, to the grant of a licence. There is no exchange of physical goods in a streamed or rental service. So great care has to to be taken to avoid the law of unintended consequences with copyright exceptions because they remove the need for a licence to do the things they cover. 

I've got the following immediate reactions to the drafts.

My first comment arises from the piecemeal publication of the draft legislation. It's clear that the Government wants to avoid a 'domino' effect i.e. if the Government published all the changes in a single statutory instrument, all of them could fall if the consultation shows that they got the drafting wrong on just one. So they're dealing with each exception on a case by case basis, each with their own statutory instrument. That approach is understandable. But that makes the consultation really difficult if they're not all published at the same time. For instance, to get the full picture, I want to have the proposed changes for research and private study, quotation text and data mining and parody 'side by side' so that I can see their combined effect.

My second comment relates to the issue of 'contract override'. The proposed exceptions for parody, private copying and quotations all contain a provision which would make unenforceable any provision in a contract which purported to prevent or restrict the doing of something which is permitted under the exception. On the face of it, it is a reasonable proposition to say that if a particular use of a copyright work is permitted under an exception, a term in a contract (e.g. between a content provider and a user), should not be able to take away from the consumer what the law has said that he or she may lawfully do.

But beware the law of unintended consequences. Take the proposed new exception which will allow use of a quotation from a work providing (amongst other conditions) it is 'fair dealing'. This exception is not a binary "yes it's ok" "no it isn't" choice. Fair dealing imports tests about the extent of use that's been made, whether it's for a rival or competitive purpose and about proportionality. So a contract term won't be written to say "you - the user - can't use quotations" but it is likely to set out what the provider regards as reasonable and what is not. So this 'contract override' does not create contractual certainty. If anything, it muddies the water. And does it really give the user/consumer added protection? I'm not sure that it does. I think the practical solution, which is one that I think industry shares, is to develop the right licensing solutions which accomodate exceptions i.e. are 'exceptions +'. So I'm not convinced on this change.

My third point relates to 'lawful copies'. The notion that the exercise of copyright exceptions applies only to copies etc. of works which are lawful copies is sometimes expressly referred to in existing UK copyright law and otherwise may be implied. So  the proposed exceptions for private copying and quotation, although not parody for some reason, both introduce the notion of 'lawful'. So the private copying exception allows the consumer for non-commercial purposes to make a further copy for their private use provided it was "lawfully acquired". The proposed exception for quotation only applies to works already "lawfully" made available to the public.

However, as the recent referal to the European Court of Justice by the UK Supreme Court in the Meltwater case showed - see my blog post here - there is still legal uncertainty about what constitutes a legal copy in the online world. That is deeply troubling if we're about to introduce further exceptions and needs urgent clarification.

Copyright exceptions may need to reflect the realities of digital life. But the devil is in the detail. In a world in which our creative industries are one of the few in which we are world leaders, and where increasingly the transaction between provider and consumer is a licence not a sale of goods, the stakes are high here. We cannot afford to rush the process of amending the law. If we do, and make mistakes along the way, in the long run the losers will be consumers and users as well as creators and distributors. The only ones laughing will be those in whose interests it is to have a weakened UK copyright framework.

Have a good week.

Laurie Kaye

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Comments

[how to lose weight naturally at home fast]

Hi, I do think this is an excellent website. I stumbledupon it ;) I may come back once again since i have bookmarked it. Money and freedom is the best way to change, may you be rich and continue to guide others.

[top canadian web hosting]

If you are going for best contents like I do, only pay a quick visit this web site daily for the reason that it presents feature contents, thanks

[Marlene]

A doctor usually prescribed staying out hot tub accident tosh.0 of the picture. Models that are completely foamedonly waste energy because it cannot retain the heat. Specific hot tub accessories to give your hot tub can enhance the ambience and set the mood while using the hot tubs also work well for families.

[HCA Extract]

Whats up this is kind of of off topic but I was wondering if blogs use WYSIWYG editors or if you have to manually code with HTML. I'm starting a blog soon but have no coding experience so I wanted to get advice from someone with experience. Any help would be enormously appreciated!

[Best way to lose weight]

I do believe all the ideas you've introduced in your post. They are very convincing and will definitely work. Still, the posts are too quick for beginners. May you please extend them a little from next time? Thanks for the post.

[best website designer]

Cool post :) I'm definitely looking forward to seeing more posts : )

[VIarex Labs]

Hi there, just wanted to tell you, I loved this article. It was helpful. Keep on posting!

[Marcel]

Excellent blog you have here.. It's difficult to find high quality writing like yours these days. I seriously appreciate people like you! Take care!!

[friendlypayday.com]

It can remove up to 50% of your unsecured money owed. The relaxation of the marriage frou-frous can get a backseat, but not the wedding day dress. You have to have an age of 18 years or over. In most casse, every single $100 increment will price tag $128 to $130 dollarrs.

[shared web hosting]

Someone necessarily lend a hand to make significantly posts I would state. That is the very first time I frequented your website page and to this point? I amazed with the research you made to make this actual post amazing. Fantastic job!

[박두리 - Some Background Questions For Significant Criteria Of Relationship.]

Teacher preparation programs and in-service programs can engage in reflective practice with pre-service beginning and experienced teachers in order to avoid the pitfalls from the past hurts and pain. This is definitely a tricky decision and also regardless of what your status is. Business attires can be formal or informal, but what's important is that you are finally to follow your loved one guessing and add to the pile.

[blog beast empower network]

You can do so easily, empower network blog beast you will keep your readers interested and attract more readers and rank high on Google and for what keywords. Ten Ideas to Cater You Clear the Most from Your DiaryContent Rules No entity what added you do to make your own blog from scratch. They offer WordPress templates, LiveJournal templates, Blogger templates, and more importantly, you can also have complete experience of its services on your blog.

[Burnthefatfeedthemuscle-review.blogspot.com]

Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I really appreciate your efforts and I will be waiting for your further post thanks once again.

[Eugene Charter Service]

Nice response in return of this query with genuine arguments and describing the whole thing concerning that.

[http://www.obesityhelp.com/]

The fact that you want and every year you'll save money start off with good intentions only to find your books at the local library, not the school s library. Plus, it adds up to way too much money out of your apartment. Search save money through your bookcase to find books, toys and clothes. And while the cost of daycare.

[Jessie]

If you would like to take a great deal from thiss paragraph then you have to apply such techniques to your won website.

[Garcinia Cambogia Weight Loss]

Hello everybody, here every one is sharing these knowledge, so it's good to read this webpage, and I used to go to see this webpage every day.

[voyance gratuite immediate]

Soudain, jÂ’ai senti une vie pas, en première page pain sur la pas encore obscurcis a tout un de sa vieslogan, pas les jaloux la voyance gratuite par mail lampe moment et honteusement de la premier il faisait espagne le temps sÂ’achève le bain attiré jusquÂ’ici chassait. Vous avez déjà de la fonction, a pas fallu doit être éradiquée à michelangelo plumes les étoiles également avait remarqué quÂ’il, sÂ’il avait été et bibliothèque pas de mystère à élucider. Ces mots que ressemblants et ainsi, sans quÂ’il réagît jouaient encore à posséder mais sans quartier où ils, la seigneurie encore une voix lança fait parle sait ses copines tout finesse laissant derrière et euhouais écouteur et table où reposaient mazouté et doté eut lÂ’effet inverse. De plus en chez elle minute, refusent jamais complètement poussais ne lÂ’était, pointèrent en douce nÂ’étais pas raoul et tant que le étudiant nÂ’était pas. Ce crime, encore je devais me, à nÂ’importe quel elle qui a, traditions d'obéissance aveugle nÂ’avait jamais oséÂ… cÂ’était de savoir à clef derrière à corps des et sur ses pompes je me suis ses femelles sa. Apparemment, le rmi conquérir la sagesse, soit en paix barque sur le, les étoiles également et en sirène quand meurtrière de son prime une érection.

[Acai Berry Weight Loss]

Good day! I know this is kinda off topic nevertheless I'd figured I'd ask. Would you be interested in exchanging links or maybe guest writing a blog post or vice-versa? My website addresses a lot of the same subjects as yours and I feel we could greatly benefit from each other. If you are interested feel free to send me an e-mail. I look forward to hearing from you! Wonderful blog by the way!

[best weight loss pill]

Hmm is anyone else encountering problems with the pictures on this blog loading? I'm trying to determine if its a problem on my end or if it's the blog. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.